It has been one of the most disastrous seasons for the New York Mets in recent memory, and it just got monumentally worse for the people calling the shots. At a press conference to announce the firing of their vice president of player development, Tony Bernazard, who took his shirt off and challenged the Mets minor league affiliate to a fist fight, the Mets General Manager Omar Minaya dropped a serious accusation. The reporter who originally reported the story of Bernazard’s wild antics was Adam Rubin, Mets beat reporter for the New York Daily News. Rubin wouldn’t be the first reporter to be critical of Bernazard, last year MLB.com’s Marty Noble wondered if Bernazard was an undermining factor on the team.
The room full of reporters were aghast when Minaya said he was hesitant to fire Bernazard because Rubin had been lobbying the team for a job in the team’s player development department.
Rubin’s face dropped and he confronted Minaya right there at the dramatic press conference.
“Are you alleging that I tore Tony down so I could take his job?”
“You have told me and other people in the front office that you would like to work in the front office,” Minaya countered.
“That is despicable you would say that.” Rubin responded
Rubin would have a serious conflict of interest if he were lobbying the same team he was covering for the Daily News, especially if he did a hit piece on the same executive whose job he was looking to take.
Rubin told reporters after the press conference that he had asked members of the team how someone could get involved in baseball positions but didn’t specifically ask about a job with the team. He also said Mets owner Fred Wilpon had invited him to his office to talk about it but he never took him up on the offer.
What is even stranger is that the general manager of the Mets would make such an accusation at the press conference, which was supposed to diffuse a bad situation for the Mets having a hot head executive on the payroll. Instead of diffusing the situation he just lit a match on an even bigger one, which is likely to have long legs.
The Mets are a disaster on the field this year, devastated by injuries mostly out of their control. This is a situation they could have controlled and will now have already bloodthirsty tabloid reporters covering the team salivating at what they might be able to dig up on the Mets general manager, already on shaky ground.
Update, 7:50 PM ET: In a hastily thrown together press conference, the second of the day, Omar Minaya said he stood by what he said at the press conference regarding Adam Rubin, but it was the wrong venue to discuss it. Mets owner Fred Wilpon defended Adam Rubin
“I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that,” Wilpon said. “I believe Adam was just doing what anybody else does. I probably get a call a week from someone asking for career advice.”
Omar doesn’t seem to understand public relations very well. Your job is to diffuse these situations so fans focus on baseball. It doesn’t really matter to anyone what your opinion of Adam Rubin is, and holding a second press conference to say you meant what you said does nothing but make a bad situation worse. If you have the goods on Rubin you better produce it or you job seems to be in as much if not as much jeopardy as Rubin’s
Ron Darling, during the Mets pregame, said he no longer knows if what he discusses with Minaya is on or off the record.
Minaya has lost credibility with the highest profile public faces to the fans of the team. I think Can’t Stop the Bleeding said it best…
“Here’s a list of things the Wilpons and Minaya don’t understand : 1) public relations, 2) journalism, 3) ponzi schemes, 4) baseball.”
Here is a transcript of the press conference and Rubin’s statement to media after the conference, courtesy of Amazin Avenue.
Omar Minaya: Once the reports came out, you know, of course we had to expedite more the investigation. Early in the process, early in the process, when the reports came out, I had to kind of tell myself, “Wow, these things are coming out.” And I say this because coming from Adam Rubin, okay, and Adam, you gotta understand this, Adam, for the past couple of years, has lobby for a player development position. He has lobby myself, he has lobby Tony. So when these things came out I was kind of a little bit, I had to think about it. And I was a little bit, you know, somewhat, kind of, we gotta find out about this. We really have to do a thorough investigation of this.
[...]
Adam Rubin: Is what you’re alleging that I tried to tear Tony down so I could take his job? Is that what you’re saying?
Omar Minaya: No, no, I’m not saying that. All I’m saying was, that I know that when you wrote the reports, but I am saying, that in the past, you have, have lobby for a player, for a for a job…
Adam Rubin: If I were interested in working in player development somewhere in the major leagues at some point in my life, how did that impact this situation at all?
Omar Minaya: I said, because, when the reports came out a lot of these things were cross… I said “Who’s writing these reports?” and I said well okay who’s writing the reports and in the back of my mind, Adam, you have told me you have told other people in the front office that you want to work for player development in the front office.
Adam Rubin: So what you’re alleging is that.. the only conclusion I can draw from that is that you’re trying to allege that I tried to tear everyone down so that I could take their position. Is that what you’re saying?
Omar Minaya: Adam…
Adam Rubin: It seems pretty despicable to say that.
Post conference comments by Rubin, you can also watch the video here.
Adam Rubin: “Just like Omar would, if you were curious about journalism, would say, “How do you get into journalism?” I would ask people, because I’ve been around the minor leagues a long time, I covered the minor leagues back in the ’90s, the Birmingham Barons, the White Sox double-A team, actually when Jerry was the White Sox skipper — so I would ask them, probe them, about how do you get jobs in baseball. If you ever kind of hear about anything in baseball that might be suitable, how do you go about pursuing a job like that? But that was the extent of it. And it’s so deplorable that he would dredge that up like that. I’ve never seen anything like that. It has nothing to do with the issue. I don’t understand how they can say I would tear someone down. I asked him point-blank, you heard. Are you alleging that I’m tearing him down, Tony down, to try and take his job. I mean, that’s ludicrous. Just absolutely ludicrous.”
Asked how he felt about the accusations…
Devasted, to be honest, because I need to cover this team. I don’t know. I hope it’s still possible, but I don’t know. I can’t cover it until they switch GMs, obviously.














Daniel Murphy Means Play Of The Year Business
By Anthony De Rosa on July 8, 2009 at 11:11 pm
Comments
I doubt you’ll see a better play than this all year. Simply incredible.